It's belief in many gods that keeps hanging him up. The next problem Euthyphro confronts is really the deep problem. One or the other of two things has to come first to be given priority, but neither can. It's a problem for monotheism as much as for polytheism. Think again about how Euthyphro's dad case is really complicated. Is Dad's act excusable, if not admirable, in light of the fact that maybe he didn't have good law enforcement alternatives?
It's belief in many gods that keeps hanging him up. The next problem Euthyphro confronts is really the deep problem. One or the other of two things has to come first to be given priority, but neither can. It's a problem for monotheism as much as for polytheism. Think again about how Euthyphro's dad case is really complicated. Is Dad's act excusable, if not admirable, in light of the fact that maybe he didn't have good law enforcement alternatives?Tags: War On Terror EssayExplanatory Essay SamplesGun Control Violence EssaysOnline News Hour Richard Rodriguez EssaysDead Poets Society Character Analysis EssayProblem Solving Policing DefinitionBest Literature ReviewData Mining Research Papers 2012
And there is a Zeus who fits the bill, in terms of his attitudes, he's the Zeus who looks out for strangers and guests. Maybe he's a mix of two Zeuses, the lightning guy and the guest guy. And oh, and there's also all those other gods. Now, presumably, two few things will be able to win the unanimous election that takes to the either holy or unholy Euthyphro thinks there may be a couple like murder is wrong.
But Socrates points out that everyone will agree that murder is wrong, yes.
But really, it was caused by the fact that everyone, gods and mortals, wants to be fair. This is an issue that comes up again and again in Meno and Republic. As I say in the book, at this point any monotheists or atheists in the audience are likely to be patting themselves on the back, looking at Euthyphro's distress.
Euthyphro's definition problem seems to be a peculiar function of his polytheism.
Euthyphro thinks it's all so plain and simple, he's so straight. Socrates asks Euthyphro, what kinds of things people always fight about and just can't come to an agreement about? In terms of what it is that they tend to fight about. But they didn't go to war over whether 100 plus 200 equals 300. The title of the movie 300 is a little bit misleading, that way. I'm going to love this movie I'm so sick of watching people fight. Leonidas screams at the Persians, this is mathematical data. If it really is just math, people don't scream about it. Consider, as an alternative, the myth of the Judgment of Paris.
If your only tool is the hammer of Thor, every problem starts to look like a nail. That's a big concession, please note, the gods are like us. You'd think from the title that it was going to be about something very objective and scientific. Paris, back then was not the city, but a mortal Greek who was supposed to have very fair judgment.Sometimes they're just lying of course, but very frequently they really think that what they did was okay.For whatever complicated reason to do with the specifics of the case.Why introduce such a complicated legal case and then not make these complications the focus of the dialogue?When I'm criticizing my student's papers, I often make this point.He was considered a very wise man by the Athenians.However there were men in power who did not care for him or his teachings; Claiming that he corrupted the Athenian youth and did not believe in the Greek gods, Socrates was put on trail. Socrates says that Euthyphro’s arguments “go around in a circle, . .[and that] either we were wrong when we agreed before, or, if we were right then, we are wrong now. If it is dear to one god, is it not dear, to another? Is piety a sort of trading skill between gods and men?We'll start the next video With Euthyphro's dilemma. Did you accidentally type holy twice there at the beginning? Lets end this one with a little quiz, which poses it. It's harder to imagine telling a myth that instructs us in the appreciation of fine moral distinctions or subtle legal distinctions even.Euthyphro maybe right that his dad is in the wrong, but he's wrong to think that his dad is simply in the wrong. Euthyphro agrees with Socrates that the gods are probably pretty much like mortal folk.